
Actor Kara Killmer from NBC’s “Chicago Fire” and the new film “Jimmy” joins us on Story & Craft to talk about her career and personal stories.
Listen on your favorite app
Actor Kara Killmer from NBC’s “Chicago Fire” and the new film “Jimmy” joins us on Story & Craft to talk about her career and personal stories.
She shares the story of Jimmy Stewart’s World War II service and the making of “It’s a Wonderful Life,” plus her years as paramedic Sylvie Brett on “Chicago Fire.” Other stories include turning down a role in Netflix’s “Hemlock Grove” and working with Cary Elwes on an early pilot. Kara also covers growing up in Crowley, Texas, switching from pre-med at Baylor University to theater, and learning from her mentor John Kirby in Los Angeles.
The 2012 film “Beyond the Mask” is how she met her husband, Andrew Cheney, and how she landed the role of Lady Julia in “Jimmy” for director Aaron Burns. She describes working alongside real first responders in Chicago and the advice Jimmy Stewart gave his twin daughters.
SHOW HIGHLIGHTS
Kara Killmer joins Story & Craft
Back in Fort Worth after “Chicago Fire”
Joining “Chicago Fire” after two seasons
Growing up in Crowley, Texas
From ROTC pre-med to Baylor theater
Hulu’s “If I Can Dream” open call
Mentor John Kirby and moving to LA
Two pilots and working with Cary Elwes
Turning down Netflix’s “Hemlock Grove”
Real first responders on “Chicago Fire”
How “Beyond the Mask” led to “Jimmy”
Playing Lady Julia in “Jimmy”
Frank Capra and “It’s a Wonderful Life”
The Seven Questions
Upcoming projects and a bread recipe
STAY IN THE KNOW
- Website: https://www.storyandcraftpod.com
- Show Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/storyandcraftpod
- Show Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/storyandcraftpod
- Marc’s Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/airpreston
- Marc’s Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/marcpreston
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Full Transcript
Kara Killmer joins Story & Craft
Kara Killmer: She came to me and she was like, "You are not a doctor." "You don't belong in the military." And she's like, "I've called ahead. The theater department still has two positions open. Go there and audition."
Announcer: Welcome to Story and Craft. Now, here's your host, Marc Preston.
Marc Preston: Well, here we go, back again, another episode of Story and Craft.
Marc Preston: Thank you so much for stopping back by, and, of course, if this is your very first episode, welcome. Thanks for checking in. Today, having a cool conversation with the lovely actor Kara Killmer. You know her from Chicago Fire, Chicago Med, Chicago PD. If it has the name Chicago in there, you've probably seen her.
Marc Preston: A fellow Texas kid. We've had a lot of Texas kids on lately. Just had Jason Salmon on last and, uh, Kara, of course, another Texan. Good to have her here talking about her new film about the late, great Jimmy Stewart. It is called Jimmy. Really looking forward to seeing this film, uh, the story about Jimmy Stewart.
Marc Preston: And, and hey, I got a bread recipe from Kara. Uh, you know, you know me. If you've been listening to the show, you know I'm all about food and cooking and, uh, she gave me a bread recipe, looked it over. It looks pretty easy, so, uh, check out the socials. I'm gonna try cooking this thing here in the next day or two and, uh, I'll post the pictures.
Marc Preston: We'll see how it comes out. Hey, uh, do me a favor. Jump on over to your podcast app. Make sure to follow, subscribe to Story and Craft. You get a notification every time a new episode comes out, and, uh, do me a favor also and like the episode. Leave a review. Uh, that way it makes it easier for folks to find Story and Craft.
Marc Preston: Uh, also storyandcraftpod.com. Everything about the show, past guests, past episodes, and hey, it's been revised, updated. A new coat of paint, if you will. So, uh, check out the website. A lot of good stuff up there. So, uh, hey, you know, I had a blast, uh, chatting with Kara. She is super cool and I think you'll enjoy the chat as well.
Marc Preston: So let's jump right on into it because today is Kara Killmer Day right now on Story and Craft. So where are you at today?
Kara Killmer: Uh, I'm home. I, uh, my husband and I just got back from, uh, from Washington, DC. We, we did a screening of the film Jimmy there, and then, uh, we also participated in, um, American Valor, which is, like, a TV special highlighting heroes, and this year we did World War II heroes.
Kara Killmer: So it was, it was so humbling.
Marc Preston: It's 'cause Jimmy Stewart was in World War II, if I'm not mistaken. That's kind of the whole thing. Yes. Yeah. You live full-time in Chicago, or, uh, whereabouts do you live?
Back in Fort Worth after “Chicago Fire”
Kara Killmer: Uh, I did for, I did for a long time. I'm, I'm back in Fort Worth. I'm from, I'm from Fort Worth, Texas. Um, and, you know, post, post-COVID, uh, when my time on, on Chicago Fire ended, my, my agent was like, "Well, you can kinda live wherever you wanna live."
Kara Killmer: Um, so, you know, so we, we came back home. We'd... I've been long distance from my family for, oh, 15 years at least, so it seemed like, well, I'm gonna get some family time while I can.
Marc Preston: Very nice. You know? Well, I'm a Richardson kid originally, so not too far, too far.
Kara Killmer: Oh, okay.
Marc Preston: Are you from Fort Worth proper, or are you from, like, Burleson, or-
Kara Killmer: I am from Fort Worth.
Kara Killmer: Yes, I am from Fort Worth proper, and then, yeah, now we're, now we're in South Fort Worth.
Marc Preston: Oh, okay. So how long did you live in Chicago for?
Kara Killmer: I was there for 10 years.
Marc Preston: Really? Okay.
Kara Killmer: Yes. I was cold. I was cold for 10 years.
Marc Preston: Yeah, people don't understand the struggle of people from Texas. It's like, okay, the Dallas-Fort Worth area, you can get that-
Marc Preston: February, that January, February it gets ki- it g- it's, it gets kinda cold, you know? It can do the- Yes ... but after that, you just, you know, your body's just not designed for cold weather. But I hear the longer you're there- That's true ... the more you adapt. Did you ever adapt to that?
Kara Killmer: Uh, uh, yes. I did, uh, for the most part.
Kara Killmer: I, I definitely came here with more parkas than, than anybody has- ... ever seen in Fort Worth. Um, I remember in my first year, Yuri Sardarov, who played Otis, he took a picture of me one day when it was, like, 69 degrees out, and I had wrapped myself in a, in, like, a fire blanket- ... 'cause I was freezing. And he was like, "This is...
Kara Killmer: I'm gonna show this picture to you in a couple of months, um, when you'll experience what true cold is." And, uh, and he did, and he was right. Uh, I've, I have never, I've never experienced it. And the thing is, is that, you know, we- Because we're, uh, we were a firefighter show, you know, we spend so much of our time outside.
Kara Killmer: You know, s- half of our episodes, if not more, we're just- I was about to, I was about to
Marc Preston: say a lot of what you do is you are, you know, you're a, a paramedic. Yes. So you're out doing stuff. That's kind of the nature of the gig, yeah.
Kara Killmer: Yes. We were out in the city so, you know, so there was a lot of, of under layers and a lot of heat, he- you know, hand warmers and, and things like that.
Kara Killmer: We were really trying to dial it in.
Marc Preston: Did they have that thing like they have on the sidelines of the Cowboys games, a cold... You know, it's like a little jet of hot air, like a little-
Kara Killmer: It, it looks like, it looks like somebody took a, a f- an engine off of a jet, yes. And, and it's blowing hot air. Um, but you know, you're also, like, on the move, and those draw a lot of power.
Kara Killmer: So it's... You know, for the most part, I spent a lot of time in the cab of the, of the ambulance. I got to know that ambulance really, really well.
Marc Preston: Hey, I got a little side question 'cause I remember watching, uh, Chicago Fire right when it, when it came out. What was the n- number of the fire station?
Kara Killmer: 51.
Marc Preston: That's what I thought.
Marc Preston: Okay.
Kara Killmer: Yes.
Marc Preston: You know a couple people in production. You know, I gotta know, was that to pay homage to the TV show Emergency by any chance or...?
Kara Killmer: Oh. You know what? That's a good question. I don't, I don't actually know why they chose 51. Maybe.
Marc Preston: Yeah, sh- I was thinking- Um- ...'cause, you know, gotta tip a hat to the great, the late, great Randolph, Randy Mantooth, of course.
Marc Preston: That was the very first paramedic kind of thing happening and-
Kara Killmer: Yes ...
Marc Preston: and he, and it was- Right ... very interesting that, you know, when I saw it, it was like 51. I was like, "Are they paying homage to the old, my old show when I was a kid, Emergency?" I'm like, "Well, I have to ask somebody someday." If
Kara Killmer: they... That's very, yeah, that's very...
Kara Killmer: I, I mean, that's a great question. I, I hope, I hope nobody goes like, "Kara, how come you didn't know the answer to that?" I, I don't remember ever, I don't remember ever discussing it with, with the creator of the show when I got there. It was kinda like you know, it was sort of like I auditioned on a Tuesday, and then I was filming the next Monday.
Marc Preston: The longer you do it- Yeah ... maybe you have an opportunity to ask those questions. Like, "Oh, that pops up," you
Kara Killmer: know? No, that's true. You're like, "After 10 years, you didn't figure out what, what 51 was?" Well- That's a good question. I'm gonna
Marc Preston: ask ... that's, that's arguably... Okay, I've had a lot of folks on from different sci-fi shows and, you know, the ones that I've watched.
Marc Preston: That's probably the nerdiest thing I've ever asked somebody, you know. It's like, "Did they name it number 51 because it virtues?" So anyway, that's- Oh, well ... my eight-year-old self has gotten his question in.
Kara Killmer: That's cool.
Joining “Chicago Fire” after two seasons
Marc Preston: So when did Chicago Fire... It was right before COVID. It was, like, a year or two before COVID, I think, was it?
Marc Preston: Like, it was, like, 2018, like, 2018
Kara Killmer: or
Marc Preston: something? Uh,
Kara Killmer: let's see. I- I started in, I think 2014- Oh, that's r-
Marc Preston: okay,
Kara Killmer: that's right ... is when I started. A- and they had, they had already filmed two seasons. Um, so it was already, it was already really on its feet by the time I got there. Um, so I had a few years without COVID, which was cool.
Kara Killmer: Um, and then yeah, we, we kind of got that dropped in our laps.
Marc Preston: I can't believe it's been, that show's been out that long. There's a whole ecosystem, you know? Like, I had s- uh-
Kara Killmer: Oh, man ...
Marc Preston: Tracy Spiridakos on not long ago. And, you know- Yeah ... it was... How did that come your way? How, was that just regular old-fashioned audition, or did, did, would the casting director- Well-
Marc Preston: already know you and-
Kara Killmer: Well, I think my, my manager, Kelly Tiffin, at the time had sh- she had, had me put myself on tape, uh, like once or twice for, for Fire. And I really... This was before people were putting themselves on tape, so I'm pretty sure... I, I think I, I got a, a scene that was sort of like an action scene, and I didn't know what to wear, I didn't know what to do.
Kara Killmer: So I, I put on like a yellow corduroy jacket and, and dragged around a, a backpack full of books to look like I was dragging around my tank. Um, I think it was for a, a firefighter named Daisy. Um, and uh, I did that, I filmed that in my living room in, in my apartment in LA. And, uh, I did one other one, and I, I can't quite remember what that one was, but Jonathan Strauss saw something in it and held onto it.
Kara Killmer: Um, and so then I think a year or two later at, when the role for Sylvie came up, he went back to his, his stash and was like, "Oh, let's, let's have this girl in." And then I am a graduate from Baylor University, and of course Derek Haas and Michael Brandt are, you know, giant. They went to Baylor years ago. Oh, okay.
Kara Killmer: And, and they, they saw it on my resume. They were like, "Oh, a, you know, a Baylor Bear." And so I came in and, and just... I came in, I think, kind of straight to, in front of the producers, 'cause they were getting down to the wire and, um, and read a scene that You know, for Sylvie and, and they kind of said, "You know, we went to Baylor too."
Kara Killmer: And I made a joke and was just like, "Oh, well I guess I'll see you guys on Tuesday." You know, um, and it, and it worked. Um, but it was, it was definitely like m- my big break. And you know, my roommates and I were, we were getting our, getting the boxes from Ralph's grocery store and packing up all of my stuff, and trying to find a sub letter, and you know, it was, it was exactly that kind of Hollywood story of like you, you went from working at Brighton Collectibles and now you're on set, you know?
Marc Preston: Well, that's, that's awesome. I, I think that, uh, to connect with someone who went to... I mean, Baylor's kind of, in Texas you got UT, A&M, they're always battling. I, you know, where does Baylor kind of fit in there? I d- I know it's where my dentists went to school, Baylor Dental School, you know. But you know, that was, and my c- my cousin I mentioned went there, and he's an orthodontist.
Marc Preston: But,
Kara Killmer: um- Yes,
Marc Preston: yes ... and actually I got, uh, two of my cousins went there so, uh, whereas the other side of the family went to UT. So there's, there's that. Of course. And I went to UNT, so I- Okay ... I don't know where I figure into this- Yes ... ecosystem. Um, so- Right ... where, where did it kick off for you? You know, going back in, uh, origin story, where, were you a theater kid in school or was this something kind of a little later on?
Growing up in Crowley, Texas
Kara Killmer: So, uh, I grew up in a small town. I grew up in Crowley, which is outside of Fort Worth. Um, and you know, where, where I was growing up it was kind of like- Everybody I went to high school with either joined the military or you became a teacher. Um, and, uh, and I had, you know, my mom was a, a music teacher for- mu- a music teacher for 40 years at Sycamore Elementary, and she, she taught music, but she was always shy, and she wanted my brother and sister and I to be able to stand up in front of a room and present without feeling sheepish.
Kara Killmer: So she had my brother, sister, and I do, uh, theater when we were really young c- and, and do dance classes and things. So we went through a program called Casa Kids, which is a theater program, um, from the Theater Casa Manana- Casa, Casa Manana. Yeah, yeah ... which is downtown Fort Worth. Yes. So, uh, so we all did main stage plays at Casa Manana when we were younger, and I kinda got the bug.
From ROTC pre-med to Baylor theater
Kara Killmer: Um, but certainly growing up, um, being in Crowley, I didn't think there was any possibility that you could actually have a career as an actor. Um, so even though I loved films and, um, and I did theater in high school, I, I, I kinda graduated not really knowing what to do, and I tried to go into Baylor in my freshman year as, like, ROTC pre-med.
Marc Preston: ROTC pre-med. Okay. So-
Kara Killmer: Yeah ...
Marc Preston: but that begs the question, what's- Let's go back. What else were you doing in high school? Were you in the ROTC in high school, or were you, uh-
Kara Killmer: No. I had no interest. I, I did, I was in drill team, which was, which was dance team. I mean, I, you know, and I became the captain my senior year and, and it's a very...
Kara Killmer: Like, drill team is a very Texas thing. Like, when- Yeah ... I mention drill team to anybody from anywhere else, they're like, "What?" And I'm like, "You know, you wear a cowboy hat and you got white boots," and they're like, "What?"
Marc Preston: Well, my best, my best friend- Um ... uh, played football at Kilgore, and they had the, was the Rangerettes out there.
Marc Preston: Oh. You know, that, that, that was, that was- Of course ... the original original, if not mistaken. Yeah.
Kara Killmer: Iconic. Yes. Exactly.
Marc Preston: And I don't- So that's what I did ... by the way, I don't mean to blow your mind, but you're talking to somebody who was actually in the Dallas Cowboy Cheerleaders movie in 1980-something. So yeah, I don't- Wow
Marc Preston: as a little kid actor, you know, it was, uh, yeah.
Kara Killmer: Oh, you totally get it.
Marc Preston: So I've got my bona fides. Yes,
Kara Killmer: you totally get it. Yes.
Marc Preston: So you're in drill team, and- I- But how did that manifest- Yes ... into ROTC?
Kara Killmer: I genuinely just thought, oh, be a, be an actor, maybe never have a job, never have money, or be in the military and be a doctor, always, always have a job, always have money.
Kara Killmer: I mean, that, that is as simple as my thinking was. And thank God- I mean, were your siblings going that
Marc Preston: direction? Was that kind of their thing, or?
Kara Killmer: No, absolutely not. No, I mean, my si- my brother kinda did a business degree at Howard Payne, and my sister was doing a business degree at, at UTA. Um, eh, but I just, I just thought, "Oh, I'll be practical."
Kara Killmer: I mean, for the first time in my life I thought, "Oh, let's just be practical." And my mom, thank God, my mom gave me the tough love. Uh, I, I did my first semester at Baylor, and it, it was not going great. And she, she came to me and she was like, "You are not a doctor." "You don't belong in the military." And she's like, "I've called ahead.
Kara Killmer: The theater department still has two positions open. Go there and audition." Um, and so I went, and I, and I, and I auditioned for the theater, and I had the best time. I mean, I, I really had such a great education at Baylor, and I got to do a lot. Um, I learned everything. It's a very holistic approach where you have to build the sets, and you have to build the costumes, and go and paint, and, and fig- you know, you have to learn the lighting, and directing, and writing, and, and all of that.
Hulu’s “If I Can Dream” open call
Kara Killmer: So it was, uh, it was a very well-rounded education to help you appreciate all of the different aspects. Um, and then my sophomore year at Baylor, I was taking an auditioning class And, uh, w- we got this, you know, there was a flyer on, uh, on one of the billboards in the hallway, um, that said there's an open casting call in Austin for an untitled Hulu reality show.
Kara Killmer: And I thought, "Oh, I'll, um, I'll just try and, and see if I can put my audition tips to, you know, to the test and see if it really works." So my mom and I drove down to Austin one weekend, and, um, and I auditioned, uh, in front of two casting directors, uh, and a producer, and, you know, they gave us a couple of sides, and you filled out this huge questionnaire.
Kara Killmer: And they were very, uh... They, they played it very close to the vest what the project actually was. Um, they were just, you know, they, they went all over the country to all of these major theater schools and conservatories trying to kind of audition all these different people. And so I did my sides, and they said, "Well, we'd really like you to stay and do a callback with a producer."
Kara Killmer: And I said, "Oh, well, thank you so much," 'cause I thought, "Oh, you're probably just saying this to everybody." I said, "Thank you so much, but I actually have to get, I have to get home, or I've got to get back to school 'cause I have a test." And, um, and they were like, "Oh, really? Uh, uh, well, we'll, we'll see if we can get the, the producer to come in now."
Kara Killmer: And I thought, "Okay." And I
Marc Preston: Oh, you th- so you thought- It was not- ... they were just kind of being nice, like, "That was great. We'll be in touch," kind of a thing, and-
Kara Killmer: Yeah. It, it was one of those situations where my inexperience somehow made me come across really, like, aloof and, and, like, "Oh, this, she sh- may- maybe she's too good for this or something."
Kara Killmer: Um, and so I met with the producer, and he explained that Hulu is creating its first original content through a reality show called If I Can Dream. It was, um, it was created by Simon Fuller, who at the time was the head of 19 Entertainment. Mm-hmm. He was responsible for the Spice Girls and David Beckham, and he was responsible for creating American Idol, and he wanted to branch into this vein of reality television.
Kara Killmer: So the idea for If I Can Dream was let's have five different types of artists living in one house in Beverly Hills and with 68 cameras streaming live 24/7, and we'll- So it's kind of like an
Marc Preston: artistic Real World.
Kara Killmer: Yes, exactly. Uh, very well put. Uh, and, you know, so it was like we're gonna open the doors s- for people to see behi- like, see behind the curtain of what it takes to make it in Hollywood.
Kara Killmer: So they kind of present this idea and, and they say, you know, we, we run through this, a scene a few more times, and they're like, "Well, we would really like to move forward with you. Uh, Kara Killmer, what do you say if... Uh, we wanna make... We want you to move you to Hollywood and make all your dreams come, come true."
Kara Killmer: That's what Michael Hurwitz said. He was a producer. And I said, I said, "Well, I'd say thank you very much, but I'm gonna finish my degree first." And they just were like, "What?" Uh, "No, really." And I was like, "No, really, I gotta go back and finish taking my test." So I was like, "I mean, I guess we'll stay in touch," you know.
Kara Killmer: So I, so they were, you know, they were like, "Well, we'll, yeah, let's keep in touch," still thinking I, you're, you're saying this to everybody. Like, well, well, where were you in school?
Marc Preston: Were you like a freshman, sophomore, do you remember?
Kara Killmer: I was a sophomore. Oh, okay. I mean, I was a sophomore. I, you know, I was like, "I'm, I'm not leaving school for this."
Kara Killmer: And, uh, so I went back, and about two weeks later, um, a producer called my mom and said, "Right, so w- we need to make arrangements. We're gonna fly Cara out to Los Angeles. She's gonna meet Simon Fuller. Um, they're gonna do a, a psych evaluation, and they're gonna, you know, kind of get some talent together to see their chemistry."
Kara Killmer: And my mother was like, "Whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa. What?"
Kara Killmer: You wanna, you wanna what? You're just gonna fly my kid out to, to Los Angeles for what? You know, so there was a, there was a lot of pressure testing for her, but we both kind of felt like, well Might as well give it a shot. Um, and, uh, you know, and the, uh, the dean of the theater department was like, "Well, it's kind of counterintuitive for us to be trying to educate our students to be able to go out and get a job, and then say, 'No, don't go out and get a job.'"
Kara Killmer: So, you know, so they kinda gave me a, a short sabbatical and were like, "Well, save your homework." Um, and I flew out with a handful of other, um, participants and did this interview with Simon Fuller, and I did a few more scenes with the casting directors, Barb Stordahl and Angela Terry. And, and they kind of showed us around.
Kara Killmer: I- we went to a couple of, like, American Idol after parties and stuff and, and kinda just met different people. Um, we stayed at the, the Langham, I think. Uh- So they
Marc Preston: were just not taking no for an answer, you know? They were like, "No, we..."
Kara Killmer: They weren't. No, they weren't. Um, and you know, there were other people there that I, that I was kind of being shopped with to sort of see are they gonna be contestants or not.
Kara Killmer: And I think they, they didn't end up going with any of the other contestants that were there while I was there. They c- they went out and found a couple of other people that I hadn't met before. Um, but they were, like, ready to film, and so, you know, they pulled... I pulled out of school for a little bit and, and then, I mean, this is so the industry where it's like you kind of move h- heaven and hell for them, and then they're like, "Oh, wait, we're not ready."
Kara Killmer: Um, and so I kinda took a semester off waiting for them to be ready, and they weren't. And my mom, of course, was like, "Well, you're not just gonna be at home sitting around. You gotta go out and get a job." So I worked at Subway, and I worked at a nursing home on the weekends, and I worked at Subway during the week while I was at home.
Kara Killmer: And then they were like, "Sorry, we're-" You
Marc Preston: know, I'm starting to get the feeling your mother's kind of like the conductor of the family. Would that be an a-
Kara Killmer: Absolutely, yes. Yeah. Um, she's, she's in charge. Um, and then they just weren't ready, so I went back to school and, uh, I did some summer school to kinda make up for what I had missed.
Kara Killmer: Um, went back to school, and then my junior year, like, by the end of my junior year, they were ready. Um, and so actually, the, the dean and the other professors wrote a separate syllabus 'cause I had something called a beyond time loan where it's like, it's a, it's a huge loan that you can redeem if you graduate in four years.
Kara Killmer: Mm-hmm. And so that was really what it was like, I've got to make sure that I have all of my credits by this date. So thankfully, my, the dean of, of the school, Stan Denman, and the other professors agreed to write a separate syllabus for me to do while I was working. And, uh, so I did my whole senior year kind of abroad whilst I worked If I Can Dream.
Kara Killmer: And what they did was they put me and four other contestants together, flew us out to Los Angeles, and we did a massive international and domestic tour where we were getting to know each other and, you know, it was Ben Elliott was the other male actor. Um, Amanda Rago was sort of their commercial actress, and then Gigliane Braga was our model, our supermodel, and then Justin Gaston was our musician.
Kara Killmer: So everybody had their own vein
Marc Preston: kind of. And I was supposed to be sort- Like everybody had their- Yes. Okay, I gotcha. Yes. I gotcha.
Kara Killmer: We weren't, we weren't really competing with each other, and I was there as sort of like, oh, your classically trained actress. Um, so we all... I mean, we flew to, we went to London, we went to, uh, Berlin, Rio, Taipei.
Kara Killmer: Um, we went to Sydney. We went to Toronto, and then we did a domestic tour going across the, you know, every major US city trying to promote this sh- show for Hulu. I mean, which was an incredible experience for a, like, 20-year-old.
Marc Preston: Oh, yeah. Um- So wait, w- was, so the show hadn't even produ- been produced yet.
Marc Preston: You're, you're just going promoting the
Kara Killmer: idea. No. So we kind of did this m- massive tour together, getting to know each other a little bit and, and then we, you know, landed back in our mansion in Beverly Hills, which was also for all of us, like, you know, oh my gosh. It's... The, the best thing that I got out of that experience was meeting my mentor, John Kirby.
Kara Killmer: Um, he is, he is known as the actor's guardian angel. He was the acting coach that they put Ben and Amanda and, and myself with, and they would record our sessions with him and, and kind of put our work out there, and he was just He was so instrumental in helping us build a foundation. And I remember getting to him and, and being like, "Well, I've, I trained four y- you know, four years in school and doing theater," and he was like, "Yeah, we're gonna have to unlearn you everything you learned in school."
Kara Killmer: Um, and, uh, and he is so great. He is, he's from Hell's Kitchen. His dad was, uh, Bruce Kirby, legendary actor Bruce Kir- Kirby. His brother was Bruno Kirby, who was in, like- Oh, yeah. Yeah ... When Harry Met Sally, and, and, uh, he was in Godfather Part II. So, um, so he's the younger brother, and, um, and, and just, just is such a wonderful teacher, and that was the best thing that I got out of it.
Kara Killmer: The, the problems with this sort of experimental reality show idea was, well, there aren't a lot of agents who want to be on a reality show.
Announcer: Mm.
Kara Killmer: There aren't, there's no audition mater- no legitimate audition material that you can do on our show with unreleased... You know, it's like everything is, it, it, it's all copyrighted.
Kara Killmer: Right.
Announcer: Right.
Kara Killmer: So there were some, there were some issues that they didn't quite think through while we were there, and unfortunately for them, we all got along. So it was sort of like we don't have drama to pull from between, like, the, the, you know, and the tension that exists between trying to hustle in, in Los Angeles, and we don't have drama coming from our actual contestants So sometimes there was a, there was a, there were some attempts- Mm-hmm
Kara Killmer: to sort of instigate things to just try and get viewership, which wa- you know, was really a, a great exposure to Hollywood and who do you trust, and I learned a lot about reality show producers. That would be a whole other podcast. Yeah. But they are- Yeah ...
Marc Preston: very
Kara Killmer: smart people.
Marc Preston: Well, no, I, I remember- Um ... back when they were doing Real World, I was in New Orleans at the time.
Marc Preston: This was about '99, I think, some- they, they did Real World New Orleans. And- Yeah ... uh, a f- a friend of mine was not dating, she was friends with somebody in the house, so I kinda got wired in. You know, I was on the radio in New Orleans. So long story short is I felt great honor that MTV had to send out an email to, or a, a fax rather back then, to all the cast mates going, "Do not talk to this guy who works at the radio station.
Marc Preston: He's giving away all of our secrets." And I wasn't trying to give away secrets, I just thought, "Hey, it's kinda cool. We got Real World in, you know, got their mansion on St. Charles," and-
Kara Killmer: Yes ...
Marc Preston: so yeah, I was a subject of an MTV fax. They're like- So I was like- ... "
Kara Killmer: Don't, don't disrupt the narrative that we're trying to
Marc Preston: tell."
Marc Preston: It, it, that's the feeling I got. Yeah. It was, it was very crafted and it's almost like they sometimes would pull the pin on a grenade, throw it in the room, and run the other way, see what happens, you know?
Kara Killmer: Absolutely. Yes. There was a lot of, there were a lot of asides where it's like you're perfectly fine.
Kara Killmer: I mean, this is just an example. This didn't happen to me, but there's a lot of asides like, "I just wanted to come and make sure that you're okay." You're like, "Why?" Well, you know, after what Ben said about you, I, I just thought maybe you would be a wreck. And it's like, "Well, what did he say about me?" It's like, "Well, I don't wanna gossip, but like, you know, he kind of said something about, like, how you did your scene."
Kara Killmer: And so it's like they kinda like just put a bug in your ear to make, you know, just making a problem where there's no problem. Right, right. Um, you know, to where they get a great scene of you trying to confront him, and he's like, "I don't know what you're talking about." You know, it's like that, there just was eventually a lot of that because we couldn't do what, what it originally set out to do.
Kara Killmer: And then, and then 19 Entertainment cha- changed leadership, and they kind of looked at our show... 'Cause I did that for nine months.
Marc Preston: Wow.
Kara Killmer: That's
Marc Preston: a-
Kara Killmer: And it- That's- It was a long
Marc Preston: time ... u- usually the shows are only, I think they get you in for, like, three months maybe. I bet,
Kara Killmer: yeah. Oh, it, it was, it was almost a year.
Kara Killmer: I finished, I finished my degree. They flew me back to Texas for one day so I could walk across the stage and get my diploma, and then I flew right back.
Marc Preston: Boy, you're dedicated. And then- You have a whole lot going on and still doing the school thing.
Kara Killmer: And then, you know, it's like the leadership changed, and they kinda went like, "What's this $14 million leak in our budget?"
Kara Killmer: And they're like, "They're out." So it was like, I mean, they were, they were deconstructing this house around us while we were trying to pack our bags. I mean, it was like, "You guys have a week-
Marc Preston: Really? "...
Mentor John Kirby and moving to LA
Kara Killmer: and you gotta get out." And that's where John Kirby, uh, was... I mean, he and his assistant, Nathan, drove me around in their car around the Valley and Studio City going, "There's a vacancy.
Kara Killmer: There's a vacancy." You know, really trying to make sure
Marc Preston: that- How cool of him to do that. I guess it's kind of like- Oh, man ... I guess, you know, maybe he's like he's a real deal dude in the industry, and he probably saw you were sold- Yes ... a bill of goods that was never gonna come to fruition- Yes ... and it's like you're really- Yes
Marc Preston: trying to do a thing, you know. At least you got the degree. That didn't fall apart.
Kara Killmer: Yes.
Marc Preston: Okay.
Kara Killmer: Yes, and, and that was really thanks to my professors and my teachers being like, "Okay, you know, um, like, we'll, we'll help you do this." But, um, yeah, and so I... You know, it's like the show ended, and I, I, I signed a lease with, uh, one of John's other students, 'cause he also taught acting classes in Hollywood and, and gave, he gave me class for free for the first three months.
Kara Killmer: Um, and then I went out and got a job at, at Brighton Collectibles, um, which was, you know, at the Westwood Fashion Square Mall down the street from me. So it, it just was... And my family, my mom and my siblings came out, and, like, I bought a car, and we, we, we, my stepdad helped me put furniture together, and it was that very, like, "Oh-
Marc Preston: I guess I'm here now.
Kara Killmer: okay." Yeah. I guess I'm here now, yeah. A- and you know, but it, but it was a A story in itself of like going from this mansion in Beverly Hills to like now we're in this small studio apartment with a, you know, a girl from class, um, that I, that I'm still getting to know and, and, uh, now I'm, now I'm here.
Marc Preston: Um- Well, how was it?
Marc Preston: I'm kind of curious because where you grew up in, in Fort- in the Fort Worth area, and then Baylor, I'm gonna, I'm just gonna say that I, I'm assuming it's a little bit more of a conservative vibe maybe, you know? With, with- Sure ... and so culturally were you feeling, uh, the, the bookends or the different, the different vibe between, you know, here you are conservative Texas vibe and...
Marc Preston: I mean, you got a front row seat, you know, with this show saying, "Okay, well maybe things aren't- Yes ... always above, above board," you know?
Kara Killmer: Yes, that's exactly right. Um, working on If I Can Dream was the perfect, uh, sort of cult- it was a, it was a controlled space for having your culture shock. It, it was very different and it was kinda larger than life, but I think also I was probably the right age.
Kara Killmer: I think when you're young and you're kinda like, "All right, I'm here doing all this," you have a, a, I had a just enough naiveté to kind of get there and be like, "This is great. I'm sleeping on four yoga, on four yoga mats that, mats that I stacked together and I'm, I'm eating some canned soup, but like, I'm here and I'm doing it."
Marc Preston: Well, to an, I think
Kara Killmer: it- You know, it's
Marc Preston: like- ... I think things at that age are still more of an adventure, you know? It's, well, you kinda went, like you said, when you got there you went in reverse. You know, you were, you're in a mansion, now you're in a, you know, a small space and now you're doing the-
Kara Killmer: Right
Marc Preston: traditional LA new actor kind of a thing. Yeah. So what was that first time that you felt like, okay, well, was it at an audition, was it maybe another class where you felt like, "Okay, now I'm really in this thing. Now I'm actually part of the machine," if you will?
Kara Killmer: Yes. I mean, and I really, really do have to give credit where credit's due, uh, in that John Kirby really served as such a shield to...
Kara Killmer: Which he did, uh, you could ask any of his thousands of students. They all felt that way about him. He really cared about his students. He never wanted anybody to be taken advantage of. He was very scrupulous about like, you know, workshops and agents and, and things like that, and he tried to kind of connect you to people that he knew were good people.
Kara Killmer: Um, and so, you know, I, I was dedicated in staying in class with him. Um, I worked a lot of different odd jobs for years. Uh, I, I thankfully had a couple of girlfriends from Baylor that I was friend, best friends with come out, and we all eventually got an apartment together, and that, you know, so that sense of community, I think that's, that's really what people live or die by in, in Hollywood, is like you've gotta have a strong- Yeah
Kara Killmer: sense of community and a strong sense of family with people there 'cause otherwise, yeah, it's like, you know, good actors come there, and then they get picked up by agents and managers that, that are like, "All right, now it's time to kind of pick you apart and turn you into what I think is gonna make you a money-making machine."
Kara Killmer: And people lose themselves, you know? Um, they, they, they lose touch with, with their love of acting. They lose touch of, with who they are, um, and, and get, like you said, kind of, kind of eaten up in the grind of it. Um, and, and I really do have John Kirby to thank for kind of protecting me from that. Um- So
Marc Preston: what you tell me about him, it, it really sounds like he's the, the antithesis of what you would typically...
Marc Preston: The stories you typically hear when somebody gets out there. You know, y- they're building up their calluses- Yeah ... and they're building up their, their armor over time, and you had somebody helping you to just do your thing without- Yes ... having to, you know, like doing air traffic control for you, you know?
Kara Killmer: Absolutely. He, he was a mentor in the truest sense. Um, and then, you know, I had-- He connected me to my, my manager, Kelly Tiffin, who I'm still with. Um, and then, uh, I had done a couple of odd jobs. Like, I, I think my first, like, paid gig was, uh, I did uh, a Grimm fairy tale story. I did r- played Rapunzel, but it was, like, the real story, the real Grimm Brothers stories, and I think it was the 3D Discovery Channel putting it on.
Kara Killmer: And so it wasn't, like, a beautiful story of Rapunzel. It's like, "Did you know that in the Grimm fairy tale she gets the face of a dog?" And I had a prosthetic and, and it was, you know, just this kind of odd thing that we shot up in Beachwood Canyon. And I, I never saw it. I don't know how it turned out, but that was the first, like, professional job I did.
Kara Killmer: And then I did a short, uh, little pop-in on Jane by Design, which I think was an ABC show, um, with Andie MacDowell for a little bit. Latoya. And I played a student, and I had one line. And I remember the... I think it was the casting director or maybe the director put three stars under my name or something on the call sheet, and I, I ke- I cut that out and I kept it in my wallet for a long time, um, 'cause I thought, "Oh, good, they like me."
Two pilots and working with Cary Elwes
Kara Killmer: So that was, you know, that was something. And I did, um, I shot two pilots. Uh, I did one with Gale Anne Hurd, um, that was... It was going to be a series, but then they wound up turning it into just a, a movie 'cause they had enough in the pilot to sort of just tr- make it a mu- a movie on USA. Um-
Marc Preston: Well, she does, like, action-type stuff, you know, mostly, doesn't she?
Kara Killmer: Oh, yeah, she had done Walking Dead and, and it would've been kind of, it would've been kind of action, uh, eventually. It was a, a I'm trying to remember what it was called, but it, it was a story about how the, uh, there was an alien invasion, but they were using the Nazis to kind of cr- give them hosts to, to invade their bodies, sort of like invad- invasion of the body snatchers.
Kara Killmer: But it centered around this one woman whose husband had gone to war, and he came back, and she thought it was her husband, but it was really an alien. Is th- is
Marc Preston: th- did this ever make it to air? Is this out there? 'Cause I gotta see this.
Kara Killmer: It did. It, it did. USA, USA aired it one time. It'll come to me what it's called.
Kara Killmer: I should've, I should've remembered. But, uh, and I played a, a German Nazi spy who was at a brothel. And so, and, and I was in collusion with Cary Elwes's character, who was playing, like, a CIA agent or something at the time. So I got to do some scenes with Cary Elwes, and he is absolutely the nicest individual ever.
Announcer: Mm-hmm.
Kara Killmer: And, and very patient with new actors. And, uh, I did that, and then I filmed another pilot, uh, called Tin Man, and I was playing a, a, like an android that turns evil. Um, and, and we really just got through the pilot, and it, and it, and it didn't go. That was with D.J. Caruso. He was the director. And so I was like, "Wow, I'm really s- I'm really stacking up some villains."
Kara Killmer: Uh, I wonder... I didn't realize that that was the impression. Um, and then I ha- you know, but I had done a coup- I'd done a handful of, of auditions for Chicago Fire by that point. Um, and then I got a new agent. Uh, I got a new agent at, at the time was APA, uh, now it's IAG. But, uh, I got a new agent, and I had an audition for Hemlock Grove that I got at the last minute, which was, uh, I think in its first season on Netflix.
Turning down Netflix’s “Hemlock Grove”
Kara Killmer: And I remember watching a few episodes of it and thinking, "This is a little too dark for me. I don't know if I can do this." And I k- I kinda told them, like, "I don't know if... I, I, I'll, I'm happy to go and do the audition, but I don't know how comfortable I feel about it." And I didn't realize this, but my agent had already gone and, like, really done the hard sell with the producers Oh
Kara Killmer: on, after my audition. They, they loved my tape, and, and so they came back on Monday, like, with an offer. And I was like, "Oh. Uh, oh no." Uh I, I, I'm so sorry. Uh, but I really, I, I really don't think I can do this. Um-
Marc Preston: So, so basically- And, uh- ... your whole career, you've sort of gone the opposite direction of most people who audition.
Marc Preston: You're like- ... "Yeah, I gotta go back to school. This is like, you know..." You, you, you like, you like them chasing after you.
Kara Killmer: I guess. Uh, and now that you say that, I, I, I guess that's true. Um, y- and, and I mean, I don't think... I think both my agent and my manager were like, "Th- this is not how this is done." Mm. Um,
Marc Preston: you know,
Kara Killmer: especially when a new ac- Was it just the
Marc Preston: vibe of the show?
Marc Preston: Were there things that, you know, you knew where you... You know that they were gonna ask of you that you weren't down with? Or was it, what was it that wasn't really landing for you? Yeah,
Kara Killmer: it, it, you know, it's like I watched the first few episodes, and it's a brilliantly done... I mean, it's a beautiful show. A- and, and Bill S- Bill Skarsgård, I think, was one of the main characters at the time.
Kara Killmer: It's just, it was very much in that horror, it was very much in the horror genre. Uh, a- and I, at the time, just felt like I, I don't know if this is the kind of story that I wanna tell. Um, you know, a- and I, and very often, f- of course, new actors feel, and this is kind of good advice, but it's like new a- actors definitely feel like you can't say no to a job you're uncomfortable with.
Kara Killmer: Like, you're, you're not in a position to say no. You, you have to, like, if you're offered a job, you take it. Um, and for the most part, I'd say that's good advice. Um, you know, build up your, build up your resume. But it's al- it's also good for you to just stick by, stick by your gut. Um, and-
Marc Preston: Yeah, I think that's pro- that right there, I think, is something that the boundaries that you set, uh, I think, kind of send a signal to everybody in the ecosystem, you know, your agent, your manager, you know.
Marc Preston: Do you think you got that from your mom, maybe, from what you're telling me about
Kara Killmer: her? I'm sure I did. I'm sure there was an aspect of like, "My, I c- I, I can't, my mother can't watch me do this." Um, but you know, it, it worked out really well because, I mean, they had, the producer called me trying to say like, "No, really."
Kara Killmer: A- and I, in hindsight, now that I know how things work, I'm like, I probably... I can see how, like, if I was offered that job now, I know because of my experience how I could make that material work in a way that I would be comfortable. But at the time, I had no concept. You know, it's, it's sort of like you can see something on the page And it reads a certain way, or there's a certain amount of exposure, or it's like, you know, it's a sex scene, or it's a, it's a, a really graphic scene that you're like, "But that's what it is on the page."
Kara Killmer: Everything can be pretty different on the day of filming. Right, right. You can negotiate terms with the director and with, you know, intimacy coordinators and things like that to make it work for you. Um, but at the time m- that, that wasn't really as much of a thing. So, you know, so I said no, and I, I said, I, I, "Thank you so much for, for, for calling me and for, and for tr- offering to, you know, to make it work for me.
Real first responders on “Chicago Fire”
Kara Killmer: I just, I want somebody to get this role that really, really wants it. I'm just not that person." And about two or three weeks later, I got Chicago Fire. Um, and so that was great
Marc Preston: So you went from the nice warmth of Los Angeles to the frozen tundra of Chicago.
Kara Killmer: Yes. Telling the stories of, telling the stories of first responders, which was absolutely an honor. Um, and, and just so touching. And I've, you know, the, the show, all three of those shows work very, very closely with the real fire department, the real police department, uh, the real hospitals that are there.
Kara Killmer: So you, you have no, um, there's no possibility of anybody walking on set and being, and feeling like a big cheese. Mm-hmm. You know, because you're working right alongside real people who just worked a real 12-hour shift, who are like, "How are you? How was your night?" And you're like, "Oh, well, I, you know, I read my script and I turned in early, and, uh, and now I'm here.
Kara Killmer: And, and how about you?" And they're like, "Oh, well, you know, we had a, we had a dry cleaner's fire. Two of the guys are in the ICU, but they'll be all right." You know, and you're like, "Okay."
Marc Preston: Well, did you ever see that- Sure ... uh, movie with Rainn Wilson, came out in the last couple of years, where he plays a, a paramedic?
Marc Preston: And it's a, a little bit of a comedy, but it's more like how he got burnt out on being a paramedic. Oh. I forgot the name of it.
Kara Killmer: I haven't.
Marc Preston: It-
Kara Killmer: I need to watch that ...
Marc Preston: it was very interesting because he was talking about the things, uh, he, he would kind of break down that fourth wall and kind of talk to the camera.
Marc Preston: He's like, "See, okay, in the real world of being a paramedic..." It, it was an interesting- Yeah ... perspective of someone. You don't see somebody on their best day. Your job is seeing people on- Yeah ... arguably one of the worst days of their life. So after a while, you-
Kara Killmer: Yeah ...
Marc Preston: it's like being an ER nurse. You just have to build up that, you know, uh-
Kara Killmer: Absolutely.
Marc Preston: Yes ... not to be callous or whatever, but what is something that have you learned, uh, over the time you've been doing, doing the show that you're kind of surprised you learned? You, like, you feel like through osmosis or talking to people, you've learned quite a bit about a thing, something technical or medical or whatever.
Marc Preston: What, what is something that you're like, "I know a lot about this thing"?
Kara Killmer: I, I know that if something is happening around me, I, I can, I will dial 911 for you. Um, I, uh, I got really good at faking being a paramedic, uh, because there's, there, you know, there's such a difference, like for us, the challenge is How can I show an intubation seamlessly?
Kara Killmer: You know, it's like we, we've got our laryngoscope, we have all, all of the airbag, we have all the, the tools, and it's like how can I do a really fast cowboy switch and sell this to camera? Um, never really like, now I feel equipped to tackle an actual emergency. Um, uh, I mean, to some degree there are certain things that I think helped us know how to keep composure when chaos ensues.
Kara Killmer: You know, you kind of get a lot of experience to know like where's help, where's water, w- you know, what do I do in an emergency situation? Uh, which is very useful. Um, and it, and it does give you a, a greater awareness for like, you know how people joke about like Jesse James always sat with his, he always sat in a restaurant facing the door- Right, right
Kara Killmer: 'cause he never wanted anybody to come behind him. It's like there's that kind of awareness that you get from like fire safety and, and, uh, you know, safety and like, uh uh, a gun, a ma- you know, like a mass shooter situation where you go, "Okay, I know what to do." Um, there are things like that. Uh, but r- really it's just kind of hearing the firefighter stories and, and what's interesting is that there were a lot of stories that people told that are just stranger than fiction.
Kara Killmer: Mm. You know, you, you... There were a lot of times where we were like, "That's gotta be in the show," but it's like nobody would believe it. Eh, all the audience would be like, "That doesn't happen in real life." So it's kind of interesting seeing them have to sort of strike the balance between like a really interesting call that, that people wanna watch, but it's also like believable.
Marc Preston: A friend of mine I went to high school with was the, um, well, you know, y- you're in the Dallas-Fort Worth area. He was, uh, for, he was the chief flight medic for Care Flight or one of the head dudes. Oh,
Kara Killmer: wow.
Marc Preston: And he said, "Now, come on out to have a party with them," and some of the, they were firemen or some of the people that are just in their, uh, tribe, if you will.
Marc Preston: And I came out. Yeah. And just listened to 'em t- the nonchalant way they would talk about the things that sound to our ears being kinda harsh, but it's like there's limited time and limited options, and they know what to do and that's... I know enough to know that that would never work for me.
Kara Killmer: It's takes a very special person.
Kara Killmer: I mean, yes, that gallows humor is, it's ubiquitous, uh, for sure. And it's been interesting, it's been interesting doing this film Jimmy where, uh, you know, as we're doing all of this press, we're doing so many veteran events. I just did the American Valor TV special in Washington, DC. L- literally a, a room full of centennial World War II vets and, and dozens of other, um, veterans who ha- they do the same thing.
Kara Killmer: I mean, it's the same gallows humor, uh, you know, similar coping mechanisms, 'cause that's what you gotta do, you know? When, when you're encountering stuff like that and that's your Tuesday-
Marc Preston: Yeah ...
Kara Killmer: it's like this is kind of the sense of humor and the sort of off-the-cuff stuff that you have to have.
Marc Preston: What did Jimmy Stewart, what did he do in...
Marc Preston: Was he in the Army or what did he do?
Kara Killmer: Ha- happy to share that. So Jimmy Stewart had, he had already made 27 films in Hollywood. He had just gotten his Oscar for Philadelphia Story, so he was like, you know, at the top at the time that he got his draft letter And the studios did everything they could to try and convince him to stay.
Kara Killmer: Um, they, they did not want him to go into the service. Um, but fun fact, the Stewart family has fought in every American war since the Revolution. Really? So, so, you know, big shoes to fill. Um, but he already knew how to fly, and so he wanted to... At the time, they had the Army, like- Air Corps, yeah ... Army Air Corps.
Kara Killmer: Yeah, they didn't have the Air Force yet, but they had the Army Air Corps. Um, and so he, he wanted to go into the Army Air Corps, and he fought the studios to be able to go and serve. He didn't wanna take a desk job. He didn't wanna just make propaganda films. He wanted to go and serve in combat. Now, at the time, uh, the average, like, at the time, the assignment was you fly 15 missions, then you can go home Uh, the statistics were that nobody survived more than nine missions.
Kara Killmer: So the statistic- Now, what, what did
Marc Preston: he fly? Was like B- was it a B-17 or-
Kara Killmer: B-17. Okay. Yes. Which is basically a flying washing, like washing machine. Right. Um, it was like very, very high manual execution, very low tech. Um, and so, you know, so he, uh, he flew 20 missions. He would plan the missions. When it was a very dangerous mission, those were the ones he chose to fly, and then he planned the other missions.
Kara Killmer: Um, and then about halfway through the war, they raised the number of missions from 15 to 30, knowing that, you know, nobody would make it to 30 missions. Um, and so he, uh- It's
Marc Preston: kind of like that movie Memphis Belle ... he was promoted. Did you ever see that?
Kara Killmer: I don't
Marc Preston: think so. Oh. I haven't. It, it came out about 1991 or '90, I think.
Marc Preston: It was, uh- Okay ... D.B. Sweeney was in it, and, uh-
Kara Killmer: Oh, okay ...
Marc Preston: oh, God, um, I can't for... whenever my brain- Memphis Belle ... tries to remember a name it goes, "Oh, no, you're not gonna remember a name, no." Uh, but anyway, but basically it was-
Kara Killmer: Of course, and
Marc Preston: you let it go. But it was that kind of an idea that these guys were, I think, heading towards the end of that number of, of flights, of missions.
Marc Preston: Uh, I didn't realize there was actually a number they gave you. It wasn't a certain tour of duty, like a certain amount of months. It was a certain amount of flights, you know, so, um-
Kara Killmer: Yes ...
Marc Preston: without giving anything away, but how did you factor into the, uh, into the story?
How “Beyond the Mask” led to “Jimmy”
Kara Killmer: So, and I forgot to say this earlier, so, uh, the reason that I got looped into this is because I had shot a film in 2012 called Beyond the Mask, uh, which was like w- it's like National Treasure meets, uh, Pirates of the Caribbean.
Kara Killmer: And the producer on that film was Aaron Burns. Uh, and his, his cousin, Chad Burns, had directed it. Um, and the, the lead of that film was Andrew Cheney. And, you know, long story short, we had a total showmance and turned true love, and he's my husband. And we've been married- Really? ... for 10 years. But yes. Um, so, so Aaron, uh, Aaron is the one who, you know, he had read an article that Jimmy Stewart wrote years before he passed about how Um, how he was so proud of his films, but the thing he was most proud of was his service in the military, and he was like, "I had no idea that he even served in the military."
Kara Killmer: Um, and how when he came back, um, playing George Bailey in It's a Wonderful Life saved his life, basically. Um, he was George Bailey. Uh, and so he, so Aaron wanted to tell that story, and so he worked on the script and, and, you know, it's, it's taken them two years to kind of get things off the ground. He needed somebody with a British accent, and I did a British accent in Beyond the Mask, and so he called me up and was like, "Hey, would you ever be interested in, in doing this movie called Jimmy?
Playing Lady Julia in “Jimmy”
Kara Killmer: I'll send you the script." And I read it, and I loved it, 'cause I love that tr- the true story behind how the making of It's a Wonderful Life. And, uh, truth be told, my character is not... I- she's one of the only fictional characters in the story. Um, Lady Julia is a British, uh, royal lady, and there were at the time in England several lords and ladies who were playing host to the Allies.
Kara Killmer: So it's like, you know, "You come to my, my providence, and, and we put you up," and, and they kind of serve in a mayoral capacity, um, to servicemen. And, um And the, the reason that they created my character is because Jimmy Stewart didn't do a lot of press while he was in the service, 'cause he didn't wanna turn it into another Hollywood circus.
Kara Killmer: He didn't want, you know, the paparazzi following him around while he's trying to do missions, and he didn't want to seem like a joke to his fellow servicemen. So he didn't do a lot of press. So there's not a lot of insight that we have into his experience there except official records and what he left in his journal.
Kara Killmer: And, um, so they kind of, they sort of created this character for, uh, as a lens for the audience to sort of observe him. She's sort of his companion through that time, uh, and, and sort of gives the audience a window into his, his missions and into the identity crisis that he was having during that time of, of just sort of like, "Am I this Hollywood star?
Kara Killmer: Am I a legitimate soldier? Am I a good man?" Mm-hmm. Um, and she kind of serves as a respite for him to sort of grapple with this identity crisis, um, you know, and also is, is kind of the, the longest love interest that he has in the film. And, and ultimately says, like, you know, "You're, you've gotta go and, and be healed.
Kara Killmer: And, and one day you'll be able to see the man that we all see." Um, so that's
Marc Preston: kind of the- So, so It's a Wonderful Life was his first film once he returned from the war?
Kara Killmer: Yes. Oh,
Marc Preston: okay.
Frank Capra and “It’s a Wonderful Life”
Kara Killmer: So Frank Capra... Uh, he had kind of gone back to Hollywood and lost all of his momentum. People were like, "Jimmy who?" Um, and Frank Capra, who was his close friend, reached out to him and said, "I have this idea for a movie about a guy who wants to kill himself.
Kara Killmer: And he's standing on the bridge, but then this angel shows up and jumps in instead and shows him what his life would be like if he never existed." And, um, and so he kind of reluctantly joins the, you know, the film and, and, uh, you know, like certainly as an actor, it's, it's interesting to me and, and very touching to me that, that for him, playing the character of George Bailey and telling George's story of like what would the world be like without George Bailey, what would the world be like without Jimmy Stewart, um, that, that through playing that character, the catharsis helped him Come into his faith and helped him make peace with his survivor's guilt and with his PTSD and, and really saved his life Well,
Marc Preston: that was back before they even had a phrase for PTSD.
Marc Preston: You know, they had, like, what do they call it? Right ... shell shock or, or whatever, you know. It was- Yes ... it was almost a reductive way of looking at it, and these, you have a whole generation who was- Right ... uh, deeply
Kara Killmer: affected.
Marc Preston: Yeah,
Kara Killmer: and his daughter said, uh, who's a producer on the film as well, Kelly Harcourt Stewart, um, she said Dad never talked about the war.
Kara Killmer: Never. Like, y- they even had a book report that they had to do where they were like, "Dad, I'm..." You know, or their, his son had to do a book report and was like, "We're doing a report on World War II. Can I interview you?" And he's like, "There's the library Like, go look it in a book. You know, and it's like, it's, it's the greatest generation, it's the silent generation.
Kara Killmer: I had a grandfather, my paternal grandfather, um, Hugh Douglas Kilmer, was a lieutenant colonel, um, in World War II. He was in the Air Force. He was in England for three years. He was a dentist, so he did all the reconstruct- He was chief of, of dentistry. He did all the reconstructive surgery for soldiers who were injured in their mouths and, and likely did a lot of identification.
Kara Killmer: Mm-hmm. Um, so saw some, some terrible things, and then he came back to the US and was the chief of dentistry for the whole national VA for, for years and years. Um, and my dad said he never talked about it. Never. Ne- not one story, not one mention. He pointed him toward a stack of books and said, "If you wanna know what I went through, go read this."
Marc Preston: I would assume, and this is just an assumption, that the reason why they did that is that if they open that back up, then it's still very much a real, living thing for them.
Kara Killmer: Yes. They wanna
Marc Preston: close the door on it. Yeah.
Kara Killmer: Yeah, they're over it. Yeah, they're ready to move on, you know, with their lives.
Marc Preston: So you're...
Marc Preston: Being back in, uh, Fort Worth, that's kinda becoming kind of the, uh, epicenter of all things Taylor Sheridan now, it seems like.
Kara Killmer: Any day now. Any day now, Taylor. Do you- Call me up. I'm a 35-minute drive to Weatherford. I'm here for you, buddy.
Marc Preston: Yeah, as, as a fellow Texan, what's it like to kinda be back and, you know, you've, you've planted your roots here.
Marc Preston: Is it... What's it like for you, you know, being back this way?
Kara Killmer: It is... You know, I always joke with everybody, even b- even before I lived here, it's like any time I visited from LA or Chicago, I just felt like, uh, you can feel your shoulders go down two inches. Like, you can kinda finally relax. Um- Mm-hmm ... and, uh, and, and you know, like you said, it's, it has grown so much.
Kara Killmer: Uh, you know, it's, it's kinda crazy how much it's just exploded, you know, not just because of, of the film industry here, but j- but every industry has, has kind of planted itself in, like, Dallas or Austin or San Antonio, um, or Houston. And, um, so it's, it's, it's become more of a happening place. Um, which is cool, because after living in Los Angeles and then living in Chicago, it's like now we, you know, we kinda know how to be city people too.
Kara Killmer: Yeah. But we, we like being somewhere where it's small. Um, you know, you can kind of- Just drive around for 25 minutes and you've seen the whole- Yeah ... the whole neighborhood. Um,
Marc Preston: but I,
Kara Killmer: you know I- A good friend
Marc Preston: of mine I grew up with is, I think he's in Burleson. That's kind of south-
Kara Killmer: I am very close- Okay ... I'm very close to Burleson.
Marc Preston: Yeah. Yeah, he, he's, you know, we, you know, being in North Dallas, you know, we grew up there. And he, he's, he's funny 'cause, you know, I'm a Jewish kid and he's not, but he loves- Okay ... he loves deli, and he said there's no decent bagel out here. Oh. You know? So, so he-
Kara Killmer: I know that's true.
Marc Preston: And so he said- Yeah ... "I gotta, I gotta drive to get..."
Marc Preston: Being down here on the island, I don't really- That's so funny ... have access to... I mean, it's been a couple years since I've had decent sushi, you know, but I digress. Sure, sure. That makes sense. So, but what's your favorite barbecue place, uh, in Fort Worth since you're a native?
Kara Killmer: Oh, that's a good question. I mean, you know, I, I, I have to say, like, my husband and I are really so healthy that we...
Kara Killmer: Like, I love to cook.
Marc Preston: Mm-hmm.
Kara Killmer: So really the question is I'm, I'm trying to learn how to make good barbecue. But, um, you know, we, we do a lot of cooking at home. We rarely eat out, which I know is kind of a travesty for, like, living close to Fort Worth. But- Oh, no,
Marc Preston: no. I, I think, I think it's, I think it's a good thing that I...
Marc Preston: Then when you go out it's, it's something special, you know?
Kara Killmer: Yes. It's a treat. Um, I mean, it's funny that your, your friend lives in Burleson 'cause we've definitely had a, a burger from Grump's. Um, you know, where you c- where you're, like, right next to the train track and you can watch the train go by and you can eat your peanuts and drink some good lemonade.
Kara Killmer: Um, so it's, you know, it's a, it's a much slower paced, um, which, which is nice, uh, to
Marc Preston: me. I think- I th- yeah, I think the last time I was there was at, uh, was it Hard Eight Barbecue? I think that's what it's called. And, uh-
Kara Killmer: Yeah. Hard Eight's great ...
Marc Preston: and, uh, but no-
Kara Killmer: Yeah, Hard Eight's delicious. That, that, that's prob- that'll probably qualify as my favorite.
The Seven Questions
Marc Preston: We get to that point in time where I do what I call my seven questions. This is my little extra bit of fun- Great ... I like to do here. And sticking with the food idea, the first question's always, what is your favorite comfort food? Great day, it adds to it, bad day, kind of lifts you up a little bit. What would that be for you?
Kara Killmer: Easy answer. Uh, I, I am a, just a sucker for a good scrambled egg, and I make, I make homemade bread every week. Really? So I have, like, a slice of homemade bread and just, like, some perfect scrambled eggs will do it for me. I was just saying that to my husband the other day where I was like, "This might be my," like, if you're on death row and it's, like, your last meal, I was like, "This might be my last meal."
Kara Killmer: Like, there's just... It doesn't get much better than that for me.
Marc Preston: Egg, eggs are a very, a, a, a noble ingredient. There is a, um, place in LA I've always wanted to go to. He's known for his omelets. A French guy. Oh, God, his, uh... I can't think. But every time I see, I, it'll show up, like, on- I'm thinking I
Kara Killmer: know what you're
Marc Preston: talking about
Marc Preston: on, like, Food Network or whatever, it's, uh, uh, um-
Kara Killmer: Yes ...
Marc Preston: his name will come to me in a moment. Like, you know. I was a big fan- Of course ... of Anthony Bourdain. I know they went to-
Kara Killmer: Ah,
Marc Preston: yes ... France together, and you know what... But I was like, I, I'm not a big omelet guy. I'm kind of just OG, you know, whatever they serve- PS
Marc Preston: in a diner kind of a guy. But I digress. Nice. Um, now, next question I got for you is if you're gonna be sitting down spending an afternoon, you're, it's gonna be you, three people, sitting at a table, cafe. You're gonna be having coffee. Living or not, who are those three people you want to be sitting at that table with for an afternoon?
Kara Killmer: Mm. Mm, mm, mm. I guess it kind of depends on what, what sort of fun you wanna have. Uh, you know, I, I think what would be fun, and educational, uh, and these are just the first people that come to my mind. Now, now I'm gonna really work on making sure I have a, a well-round- rounded answer to this in case I get asked this again.
Kara Killmer: But what first comes to mind is, um, especially having just done this film, Jimmy, uh, you know, Jimmy Stewart is kind of the trifecta. Like, he's an amazing Hollywood actor, this incredible soldier, and I think a true American. And so I would, I would want to have him at the table. And then I think I would pile on to that and, and have Ronald Reagan And maybe m- my other favorite president, which is Teddy Roosevelt, and just see what happens.
Kara Killmer: Um-
Marc Preston: See, I like that. I al- Let me just see- I always say it's not just about the conversation with you, but you get to watch them having a conversation.
Kara Killmer: Yeah, yeah. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Uh, yeah. That's, that's kind of where I was like I, I probably wouldn't even have to say a thing. Um, but, uh, I, I would, I would like to enjoy that conversation I guess.
Marc Preston: Yeah. You know, regardless of what you think of his politics, Reagan, it would be nice to have a president again who spoke like him, had that... I think it's 'cause he's an actor, right? You know, he was, he had the ab-
Announcer: Yes ...
Marc Preston: he had the, they called him, what they called him, a great communicator or whatever, but he, uh-
Announcer: Yes, yes
Marc Preston: one thing I do loved ab- love about him, you look back at his speeches, and his speeches were written to be the way people speak as opposed to- Hm ... political speak. Um- Right ... you know, I think I was in elementary in, I think I was in elementary or junior high, you know, when, when he was president, but got him feeling old now.
Kara Killmer: You know, when we were in DC I met l- uh, David Truglio, who used to run the Reaga- the Reagan Library in, um In, in California, and I, I, I told him, I said, "You know, the Reagan Library is my Disneyland." Really? Um, 'cause I, I love it. I, I loved, I loved going there and because of his speeches and, uh, you know, he's like, "Well, which one's your favorite?"
Kara Killmer: I said, "The Barry Goldwater speech." But, you know, exactly right that, that, like despite what you may think about his politics, I love him because I feel like he was the last president who could really sell an idea. He could really sell his policies to the American people. He was so good at taking his ideas and going, "Now, this is what we wanna do."
Kara Killmer: And, you know, I just- He, you
Marc Preston: know, part of it is I think he had humor, which was on, on demand. You know, he could access- He yes ... that pretty easily, you know?
Kara Killmer: Yeah, he had some zingers.
Marc Preston: Oh, did you ever see a thing where- He did ... he was doing, uh, I don- I don't know if it was a s- it was some kind of a speech he was going to do, and I think they were just getting everything set up, and he was like, "You know, the Russians- Yes
Marc Preston: are attacking," or whatever, you know? And apparently, they, they-
Kara Killmer: Yes ...
Marc Preston: whoever was recording at the time, so that became, you know, a, a thing.
Kara Killmer: Yes, that was the... Yeah. I r- I know what you're talking about.
Marc Preston: Um, now-
Kara Killmer: Yeah ...
Marc Preston: now the next question I got for you, going back, uh, back when you were youngin', uh, who was your very first celebrity crush?
Kara Killmer: Okay. I was not typically somebody who had... Like, I, I was never into NSYNC or Backstreet Boys, and I would be so embarrassed if he ever, if he ever heard this. But when I was 15, I was really into Lord of the Rings and Pirates of the Caribbean. Mm-hmm. And my best friend Beth and I loved Orlando Bloom.
Announcer: Oh,
Kara Killmer: of course.
Kara Killmer: Um, so I ha- Yeah, yeah ... I had all of, you know, I, I, I know way too much about hi- I know more about him than anybody ever should, and I had every poster, and every notebook, and every, everything you can imagine. Oh, really?
Marc Preston: Okay. So g-
Kara Killmer: Oh, yeah. Did, did you ever see, uh-
Marc Preston: It was, it was hardcore ... did you ever see Elizabethtown?
Kara Killmer: Of course.
Marc Preston: Okay. Yeah.
Kara Killmer: Of course I did. I asked the movie theater if I could have the poster when they were done, and they gave it to me, so yes. I did see it. Um, now I look back on that and go, "I hope nobody ever feels about me the way." It's way better like... That there's just, it's a bunch of energy that goes nowhere.
Kara Killmer: You know, it's like he doesn't know I exist. It, it, it, but it was, but it was a part of, you know, those films, uh, are so, they're so fun, e- especially, like Pirates of the Caribbean is just so fun. And that was, you know, really when I was 15 was the first time that I was like, "Could I do that? I mean, that just looks like a gas," you know?
Kara Killmer: Yeah. Uh, so, you know, he's kind of instrumental in that, but I'm, I'm, I'm embarrassed to say so.
Marc Preston: I thought Elizabethtown- Yeah ... was, was a cool movie. I don't know. I thought that was, uh-
Kara Killmer: Of course.
Marc Preston: Now, the next question I got is, it, it kind of going to Pirates of the Caribbean. Let's say you got a beautiful island you're gonna be living on.
Marc Preston: It's, it's an exotic island, but it's a resort. You, you know, you're comfortable there. Mm. You're gonna be there an entire year, but no streaming. Mm. So if you wanna listen to music, you can bring one CD or a box set And if you wanna watch a movie over and over again, you can bring one DVD. What would the music, what would the CD be, and what would the DVD be for the entire year for you on the island?
Kara Killmer: Hmm. Well, I, I love classical music. My mother's a music teacher, okay, so we were brought up on classical music. I would probably have some sort of, like, greatest hits of Mozart or something- Mm-hmm ... just because it feels like, you know, there's a Mozart song for, like, every mood that you could be in. Um, love that.
Kara Killmer: Uh, in terms of a film, I have, like, a handful of, of films that I feel like would fall into this category of What's your comfort film or, like, if it's on, you'll just let it play. Yeah, yeah. Like if you're skip- you're surfing channels and it pops up, it's like, "Oh, this is, this is great." Um-
Marc Preston: That one you don't even need to look at.
Marc Preston: You know what the next line is, yeah.
Kara Killmer: Yeah. A- and for me, that's, that's gotta be... I feel like my answers aren't gonna lend me any sort of, like, cultural, like, "Oh, she's, you know, she's so intelligent," and I don't care. Uh, I love After the Sunset with Pierce Brosnan and Woody Harrelson. Uh, like Woody Harrelson and, uh, Salma Hayek.
Marc Preston: Oh,
Kara Killmer: yeah.
Marc Preston: Uh- Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
Kara Killmer: It i- it- I just, I just love it. It is a good film. Um, I love Julie and Julia. Uh, I love Fried Green Tomatoes.
Marc Preston: Of course, yeah.
Kara Killmer: Um, basically any film that Thomas Newman was the composer for, I'm a sucker for. All of the films that he... Phenomenon, uh Pay It Forward. Um, what's the film that, that, uh-
Marc Preston: Well, y- well, the movies you're giving me are all kind of of a certain era, too.
Marc Preston: You know, you were probably late teens. Yeah. About, about early 20s.
Kara Killmer: Sure.
Marc Preston: Yeah, those are all of a certain era, yeah.
Kara Killmer: Yeah.
Marc Preston: Now, next question I got for you. If you were to say from the time you get up to the time you go to bed, at the end of the day, you go, "God, this w- this was a perfect day," what were the ingredients?
Marc Preston: What would be the component parts of a day that you could say, "This was a perfect day for me. These things happened, got a chance to do this, see these people"?
Kara Killmer: Yeah, I mean, a perfect day for me obviously starts with homemade bread and scrambled eggs,
Marc Preston: as you know. Uh, well, any particular bread, though?
Kara Killmer: Uh-
Marc Preston: Any specific, uh-
Kara Killmer: Well, like, you know, the homemade, my h- my homemade bread, it's like a, it's just like an artisanal, like you s- you whip it all together, you let it proof, and then you stick it in the Dutch oven, and it comes out like this perfect little thing.
Kara Killmer: It's... I, I got it from a, a recipe called, it's a chef whose page is called RecipeTin Eats. Um, and she was like, "Here's the easiest bread you've ever made," and now I make it every week.
Marc Preston: I miss it 'cause we don't have a, like, we had a Whole Foods, you know, where we... You know, they had that little bakery, you know, and that- Of course
Marc Preston: those fresh breads and, and we don't have that here. So I'm like, "Well, I gotta, maybe I'll make one." Right. Maybe you've inspired me to do that. Well,
Kara Killmer: post-COVID, I learned how to do all the sourdoughing and all of that and, and this is like, this is easier than sourdough, but it's still delicious. Um, I'll send, I'll send you the recipe.
Marc Preston: Perfect.
Kara Killmer: Um-
Marc Preston: Perfect
Kara Killmer: But, uh, yeah, spending some time with my family, especially now that we're, that we're close together. My mom is, you know, she's still in the house that I grew up in, my mom and my stepdad, and, um, and my brother and sister are kind of spread out, but it's like at least we're all in Texas.
Kara Killmer: But, you know, in Texas, you, it's still a long-distance relationship 'cause you're, you know, four hours away, and you're not even halfway down the state. But, uh, spending some time with family and, uh, for me, I'm, I'm a big crafter, so I love, I love to craft. Uh, I've, I build... If I, if I wasn't an actor, I would, I would be somebody who makes, like, the window displays at Anthropology.
Kara Killmer: If you told me that, that my job was to sit for 90 hours a week in a, in a room, like putting little, little beads on, you know, a piece of parchment or, like, having to paint and spray and glue and, uh, you know, fold all kinds of material to, like, make a beautiful display, I would be like, "Sign me up. I'm, I'm good.
Kara Killmer: I'm... I can listen to a podcast or throw on Fried Green Tomatoes, and now I'm, you know, gonna craft the rest of the day." That is so satisfying to me. Um, and I, you know, I remember in, in, at Baylor, there was a f- uh, one of my classmates who graduated a year earlier than me said, he said, "The best advice I could give is you always have to have some kind of art that's just for you."
Marc Preston: Yeah. Yeah.
Kara Killmer: I agree. Yeah. Not art that you sell, not art that you, uh, you know, that you make, you know, even to show other people. It's just the art that you make for yourself. You've gotta have that resonant- It's not
Marc Preston: a meditation, but it's sort of like your thing. It doesn't have to make sense to anybody kind of a thing.
Kara Killmer: Right. It, it's like you can't... It's artwork that you can make where it's never wrong. Whatever you do in this space of artwork, it's always the right... It's always right. It's always, you know, just pure expression of whatever you're doing. So I have, I have a lot of things in my closet and, and stuff like that that I will every once in a while will pull out, and will s- you know, do stuff.
Kara Killmer: But, um, so if I had a perfect day, I would get to do some of that and, um, and, uh, you know, I love just... I love cooking for my family. I love going for walks. Uh, it would be a p- probably a very mundane sort of day for me. It's, it's kind of like, um, you know, there's like a verse in Ecclesiastes that says like, "Do, do it unto God.
Kara Killmer: Like do your work, go home, eat, drink wine, eat bread, and go to sleep. Like do it for God and, and enjoy it." Like these simple, these simple things that we have in this- It's kind of,
Marc Preston: it's kind of like you're in a state of, uh, flow with living life. You know? You just kinda... I don't know if that makes sense.
Marc Preston: Yeah. It's sort of like the things that feel comfortable to you, that, that, that you enjoy.
Kara Killmer: Yeah. There, I think there's a... It's very easy for us to kinda take for granted some of what we would consider the grind or j- or the mundane, where it's like we're very, very privileged-
Marc Preston: Yeah. Oh,
Kara Killmer: I think so ... to be able to even, to, to think of, "Oh, my perfect day would be Eating a meal, having running water, being able to do something fun and take it easy.
Kara Killmer: It's like it's such a privilege that we would even be able to consider that as a perfect day, you know? So it's like I, I don't want to play down how doing some of those simple things-
Marc Preston: Always have to remind myself, uh, uh, when I say have to do this, have to do that. The other day I was like, "I gotta take the dog out for a walk."
Marc Preston: You know, which, which I enjoy, don't get me wrong. I l- he's laying right next to me. Sure. But we got the beach right here, so like- Yeah ... why am I not saying, "I get to go take this little guy for a walk"? Yeah. Words you choose g- do have an effect on you. You know, so I say, "I get to do that." Absolutely. I get... By the way-
Kara Killmer: Yeah
Marc Preston: a little side note on the bread, something I used to do for my kids, and since you make your own bread, you can't do this with regular bread. It's gonna fall apart, but you get a good thick slice. You, you, uh, put a little, uh, uh, olive oil on it, put it in a pan. It's gonna get a little toasty, right? Take a clove of garlic, like rub it on the bread- Ooh
Marc Preston: right? And then you put, I do like the over easy egg. Oh. And then I used to grow all of my own herbs. I haven't done that down here, but I'd do a little chiffonade of basil on top. Ooh. A little salt, a little pepper. Oh,
Kara Killmer: amazing.
Marc Preston: And it's-
Kara Killmer: Are you-
Marc Preston: It's a simple thing- Wow ... but it's a perfect thing, you know.
Kara Killmer: Oh, that's exactly what I'm talking about.
Kara Killmer: That sounds delicious.
Marc Preston: But you gotta- I mean- But it r- Ooh ... you can't use garlic powder. You gotta take the garlic clove and rub it, and it kind of dissolves into the bread.
Kara Killmer: Of course. Totally different animal using the real thing.
Marc Preston: Yeah. And, and, and- Oh,
Kara Killmer: that's
Marc Preston: good ... you can tell I haven't eaten today, 'cause I'm sitting here going, "Oh, that sounds good right now."
Marc Preston: I'm l- I k- I keep looking over to my kitchen going, "I'm going in there after I get done with you."
Kara Killmer: Oh, no. Yeah. Um- I will send you that, uh, recipe immediately.
Marc Preston: Oh, I'd love, I'd love that. Hey, you know, you've already answered the next question, what would you be doing for a living? If this wasn't available to you-
Kara Killmer: Yes
Marc Preston: you would be doing something- Yes ... crafty. You've already kind of, you know, so that's- Yes. It seems like to me you like kind of being in your, like you said, doing the window displays, and be kind of like you're in your own head, in your own space just kind of creating is kind of a happy place for you, I assume, right?
Kara Killmer: Yes. Yes. I am often in my own world, for sure.
Marc Preston: Are you, are you one of these crafters that has, that takes over the kitchen table and things like that, where your husband's like, "Okay, you know, it's, uh, where are we eating tonight 'cause you got all your stuff here"?
Kara Killmer: Yes. Whatever the spa- whatever the unfortunate space is where a project begins It, it is, it's like once it's out, it's out.
Kara Killmer: Um, I'm... And, and over COVID, I really got into building mobiles. And, uh, and so it was, like, m- uh, every kind of multimedia. I made, I made paper flowers, and then, uh, you're taking beads and you're stringing them, and you, you know, you've got fishing wire and, and hot, the hot glue gun is out and, uh, you know, and like, "Oh, here's a bit of moss," and, uh, "Oh, here's a string of lights.
Kara Killmer: How do we use that?" You know, so it's, it's, yes, I take over. Um-
Marc Preston: I, I'm, I'm kind of the same way. Whenever I, whenever I got something going on... Well, my three kids are off at... Well, two of them have already graduated, but one's still in college, and so it's kind of like, how can I fill my days so I don't acknowledge the fact I've got the empty nest going on, you know?
Marc Preston: So-
Kara Killmer: Right ...
Marc Preston: I'm always
Kara Killmer: finding- Sorry, your r- your room has been turned into, fill in the blank.
Marc Preston: No, they won't- Um- They will not put up with that. Yeah, no, that's, that's 100% - Oh,
Kara Killmer: good. Okay ...
Marc Preston: they like having their place to land at when they do get here. Um- Good ... but the last question I got for you, i- if you had that DeLorean, you could jump in it, you can go back to when you were 16 years old, and you got a couple minutes with you, or a few minutes, to drop a piece of wisdom or advice...
Marc Preston: Sorry, my little guy's talking over here. He's a- Well, good ... he's, uh, he's... Yeah, he's No. No. He's, so he's kind of like, "It's time to play." He's
Kara Killmer: hungry too.
Marc Preston: He's, he- he's like- Yeah ... "It's time to play," and he's still like an adolescent. Um-
Kara Killmer: It's great. W- He's so cute ...
Marc Preston: so if you could go back in time, what, what would you offer yourself as that piece of advice to 16-year-old you that get you on a little bit different path, makes that moment you're living in somehow better?
Marc Preston: What would that be?
Kara Killmer: I don't know if I would... I don't think I would change anything. I think I would say, "Keep doing what you're doing. It's all gonna work out." And you know, and I, I, I think I can say that really only because I had mentors like, I had mentors like John Kirby. When I was on Chicago Fire, I had a mentor like Steve Chikerotis, who was a 35-year, uh, fire chief who advises on our show, and he did the same thing, you know, for me in Chicago that John did for me in LA, which was like, "Send me that apartment that you're looking at, and let me tell you if it's safe."
Announcer: Yeah.
Kara Killmer: Uh, you know, and, and he went and saw... I, I went back to Chicago for a screening of Jimmy, and I took him with me, and, um, he was my family there, and John was my family in, in Los Angeles. And unfortunately, John Kirby just passed away, uh, this past August from battling, a three-year battle with ALS.
Announcer: Mm.
Kara Killmer: Um, and it was just wonderful to see how many hundreds and hundreds of actors came to his, his funeral, visited him in the hospital, because they all felt the same way about him that I did, which is, "I couldn't have done this without you."
Kara Killmer: Um, and so for me, it ha- my life has been marked by a series of of very equipped and wise guardians, uh, to kind of say, w- um Help me keep my heart intact, uh, and, and really protect me from some of the, the harder stuff that's out there and, and keep me on a, on a path of integrity. And, um, I, I will forever be so grateful for, for those people in my life, including my mother.
Kara Killmer: Um-
Marc Preston: Having those mentors is... You never really... What's funny is you sometimes at the very inception of the relationship, you don't realize this person's gonna have a pretty large impact on my life, you know? Sure. And you're gonna refer to them as a mentor, and right then it's just they're... You don't really, especially from your early 20s, you don't always appreciate necessarily the way you will when you're a little older and go, "Oh, wow, this person really went above and beyond."
Marc Preston: And that's like- Yeah ... that's, that's where the pay it forward, I think, thing comes in because it's like, okay- Yeah ... who can I do that for, you know? I, I think that's kind of one of those things that, uh, hopefully we never lose as a culture is, like, just, you know, be a mentor where you can, you know, 'cause you never really realize you-
Kara Killmer: Well, and Jimmy Stewart, uh, when his daughters, his two twin daughters were getting ready to go to college, he pulled them into his office and said, "All right, girls, we need to, we need to talk about something before you leave."
Kara Killmer: And they all, they both thought, like, "Oh my God, we're a little old for, like, the talk." "Um, where is this going?" And he said, "If, if you take anything with you as you go out into wor- into the world, I just want you to take this one thing with you: Be kind to people. Just be kind." And, uh, you know, it's like you see, you see this person with this entire history behind them.
Kara Killmer: The fact that, that for him wisdom distilled is kindness, uh, is another, is just another of the many reasons why he is, you know, worthy of, of accolades at this point. And, and, and certainly working on that film, uh, and learning more about him, that is the charge that I take from, from making that film was, is just like how do I look at my life and choose to do what's right versus what's easy, um, and, and, and go forth and be a, a, an agent of kindness-
Marc Preston: Yeah, I think being kind-
Marc Preston: in, in my life ... the golden rule, it's one of the very few things you could say is truly universal. It's just if you do that, you're gonna be a g- okay human. You know? Just-
Kara Killmer: Yeah ...
Marc Preston: you know, and pay it forward again. Yeah.
Kara Killmer: Well, and doing it, you know, do... we're such a, uh, we're such a transactional society, and, and so I think d- doing kindness for the sake of kindness, not because you're trying to get something out of it, not because you're hoping that in some form or fashion it comes back to you in some way, but doing it because, because you feel a responsibility to it yourself, because you need to be able to look at yourself in the mirror and, and see a certain thing is...
Kara Killmer: I, I think it's, it's important.
Marc Preston: Ab- absolutely. What else, do you have anything in the, uh, i- in the irons, in the fire, anything in the can that's gonna be happening here soon?
Upcoming projects and a bread recipe
Kara Killmer: Yeah, I have, uh, one of the directors from Chicago Fire, uh, Matt Earl Beasley, uh, he's written a beautiful film called Front Terrace, which is kind of a, it's sort of a, like, Crash.
Kara Killmer: You remember the movie Crash? Yeah, yeah, yeah. Where it's sort of like, trying to grapple with some issues, but from all the different facets of it. Right. A, a very intersection, you know, lots of intersections of, of people kind of interacting. And so this is similar to that, uh, but it's, it's really a story that's kind of some from the perspective of a border patrol agent, and some from the perspective of an, an immigration lawyer, and some from the perspective of immigrants who are trying to flee Mexico.
Kara Killmer: And so it's kind of told from these multiple angles and very, and done very eloquently, um, a- and very timely. You know, but it's, it's one of those things that's kind of in, like, pre-pre-production. Yeah. So we're, you know, we're trying to get it, get it, uh, ready to go. And then, um, a script supervisor from Chicago PD, uh, Patricia Frontain, she is, is working on a film that's based on a book.
Kara Killmer: Uh, and, uh, that's kind of a little bit like A Christmas Carol, a little bit like, um It's, it's sort of a- about a woman who's able to kind of go back in time and visit her family around Thanksgiving and, and sort of see how this, this one holiday sort of put, put her on a trajectory of her life that, that she's sort of like, "Oh, I, I, I didn't realize that, that this was positive what was happening."
Kara Killmer: Um, and, uh, so it's called You Cannot Mess This Up.
Marc Preston: So- Well, it's really nice you have those relationships that are still kind of manifesting- Oh, yeah ... and giving you opportunities. Yeah. It's great to see. Yeah. You know, you're doing... You're, you're, you're staying busy, and you're doing it from- Yes ... Fort Worth, so all is good in the world.
Marc Preston: Yes. You know? But-
Kara Killmer: And then, you know, of course any day that Taylor Sheridan wants to call me up, I'm here, you know, of course.
Marc Preston: I've had a number of the folks who were, uh, i- in his projects. Everybody loves, you know, working with him. Ranger, he already knows- Yeah ... when I'm wrapping an interview visiting with him.
Kara Killmer: I love it.
Marc Preston: He, he did- He's
Kara Killmer: so cute ...
Marc Preston: he, he's way more intelligent than I am. I know, I know. I'm actually- He
Kara Killmer: understood that.
Marc Preston: Oh, yeah. Really enjoyed sitting down and, and chatting with you. Always good to have a fellow Texan on. Always, uh... I'm s- you're-
Kara Killmer: Always good ...
Marc Preston: I'm even here drinking my H-E-B water, you know?
Kara Killmer: Um. Oh, look at you. How do you have H-E-B? That is awesome.
Marc Preston: Yeah.
Kara Killmer: Do you have an H-E-B in San F- in-
Marc Preston: Yeah, we have an H-E-B in- ... in San Francisco? ... Port Isabel. Just got across the bridge and you got it right there, so you know.
Kara Killmer: Oh, that's awesome. I,
Marc Preston: I, I- I love it ... understand the cult of H-E-B since I've moved down here.
Marc Preston: I, I get it now. But they don't have bread that's nearly as good as yours I'm sure, you know, so.
Kara Killmer: Sure, sure. If I send you something in the chat, would you get it?
Marc Preston: I, I do. Yeah, there is a little chat here, so I would get that. Here we
Kara Killmer: go. Here, I'm gonna send it to you right now. Okay, you are welcome. It was the easiest thing in the whole wide world.
Marc Preston: Now, okay- You're welcome ... and it's crusty. It's g- see, there you go, so that's the kind of bread you do that recipe I was talking about.
Kara Killmer: Um- You could have bread this evening. I mean, it takes three hours to make. You're good to go.
Marc Preston: Thank you.
Kara Killmer: There you go.
Marc Preston: Thank you very much.
Kara Killmer: I'm so happy I could help.
Marc Preston: Every time I eat that I'm gonna be thinking of you, and, uh, you know, I'll, I'll, I'll post a picture the first, the first, uh, loaf I make.
Marc Preston: I'll, I'll post a picture. You
Kara Killmer: had better.
Marc Preston: No matter how ugly it is- Okay ... I will post. But, uh- Well- That's right ... go have a, a wonderful rest of, uh, your week here, and thank you for joining me. Thank you. And I'm looking forward to seeing Jimmy, and, uh, so is my dog down here, and so. Thank
Kara Killmer: you.
Marc Preston: So hopefully
Announcer: we'll have
Kara Killmer: a
Announcer: chance- Good
Announcer: to catch up
Kara Killmer: down the line. Thank you for the time. Yeah. I love it. Thank you, Marc, so much.
Marc Preston: Well, there you go, the very lovely and cool Kara Killmer, a fellow Texas kid. Jazzed to have had the opportunity to sit down and chat with her for a while, and doggone it, I got myself a bread recipe out of the deal.
Marc Preston: So, you know, it's, it's a good news day for me. Uh, don't forget Jimmy is in theaters right now. Kinda hearing and seeing the full story of Jimmy Stewart would be, uh, a cool experience. So I'm gonna get on out there and grab a bucket of popcorn and get it done. Again, Kara Killmer, so much fun. I, I really enjoyed this conversation with her.
Marc Preston: So jump on over to storyandcraftpod.com. Everything about Kara, it's all right there. And plus you can check out past episodes, check out social media links, uh, for me and, and for all the guests. It's right there. Uh, do me a favor also, if you would. Grab your podcast app, make sure to follow and subscribe to the show.
Marc Preston: That way a new episode comes out, boom, you got yourself a notification and, uh, there you go. Also, if you leave a review, leave some stars, uh, just helps people to find the show and I appreciate that. And of course, as always, thank you very much for making what I've got going on here part of whatever you've got going on.
Marc Preston: It means the world to me. So thank you very much. Uh, go have a great rest of your day. Back with you in a couple days for another great conversation right here on Story and Craft.
Announcer: That's it for this episode of Story and Craft. Join Marc next week for more conversation right here on Story and Craft. Story and Craft is a presentation of Marc Preston Productions, LLC.
Announcer: Executive producer is Marc Preston. Associate producer is Zachary Holden. Please rate and review Story and Craft on Apple Podcasts. Don't forget to subscribe to the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or your favorite podcast app. You can subscribe to show updates and stay in the know. Just head to storyandcraftpod.com and sign up for the newsletter.
Announcer: I'm Emma Dylan. See you next time and remember, keep telling your story.

Kara Killmer
Actor
Kara Killmer is a versatile performer known for her role as “Sylvie Brett”, the dependable paramedic in Firehouse 51 for 10 seasons of NBC/Dick Wolf Films “Chicago Fire”.
Born and raised in Texas, Killmer graduated with a BFA in performance from Baylor University.
She moved to Los Angeles and was selected from thousands of young actors to star in the Hulu original series “If I Can Dream,” a show created by Simon Fuller that explored the lives of aspiring actors. Following the series, she was immediately cast in the leading role in the independent film “Beyond the Mask,” and she followed the film with a role in the USA pilot “Horizon,” produced by Gale Ann Hurd.
Shortly thereafter, she was cast in her first leading role in the NBC pilot “Tin Man.”
In 2017 Kara starred in the independent film “My Husband’s Secret Life” as Jennifer Jones, a young woman who discovers her husband is withholding a dangerous secret.
When Killmer is not working, she enjoys writing, painting, hiking and spending time with family and friends.